Hypothesis
Independent planning proposals can expose different trade-offs when evaluated against one shared brief.
LAB 002
Can three agents independently solve the same floor plan?
Independent planning proposals can expose different trade-offs when evaluated against one shared brief.
Planned
Design or workflow problem
Independent planning proposals can expose different trade-offs when evaluated against one shared brief.
Setup, inputs and constraints
Give three isolated roles the same synthetic shell, fixed openings and dimensional constraints. Preserve their separate reasoning until comparison.
Agent and tool architecture
Shared context → three spatial roles → objective constraint checks → designer comparison.
Human approval points
A person approves inputs, proposed design choices and release of the candidate. No autonomous production edits or machine operation.
Result
Not run. This record defines the experiment; no performance result is claimed.
What failed / failure tests
Test blocked circulation, changed openings, copied proposals and unsupported dimensional assumptions.
What changed
Baseline protocol. Revisions will be recorded alongside the run that motivated them.
What was learned
No findings recorded. The criteria below define what the experiment must establish.
Acceptance criteria
Report viable, rejected and untested alternatives separately. The designer explains the selected trade-off.